This article demonstrates how risky it is to assume humans can manipulate their hormonal balance externally and expect good results. Oxytocin is a powerful hormone, and it makes sense that squirting it into the brain via the nose is a bad idea over time. For years, experiments have been pointing in this direction, but lately, a rash of experts have been ignoring the implications of earlier distasters stemming from long-term administration of oxytocin. Finally, this team did a much needed experiment on long-term effects of oxytocin administration. NOTE: Bonding behaviors allow your brain and body to produce oxytocin just where it's needed, without flooding receptors elsewhere in the manner of a nasal spray.
First off, this study on a molecule tied to social interaction was conducted in animals. So I’m supposed to turn on the siren and the flashing red light here to let you know that the headline you just read might not apply in humans.
Still, the animals in question, prairie voles, are a special case, models of faithfulness that put humans to shame when it comes to the delicate topic of monogamy.
Once hitched, the rodents stick with their mates for life — an example of moral pulchritude [rectitude?] in the animal kingdom that many of us human sinners can never hope to emulate. It could easily become the state animal for whole regions of the U.S.
For just that alone, the implications of the experiment in question are particularly intriguing. The new research shows that oxytocin, the bonding hormone, is sometimes capable of turning the upstanding rodent into an anti-social lout, making the study results more compelling in many ways than if they were reported in errant humans. So the man-bites-dog headline stays.
This all came up when Karen Bales, a professor at University of California, Davis, wanted to know what would happen if oxytocin gets administered for lengthy intervals, not the short-term dosing that has occurred in the multitude of previous vole studies that linked the hormone to monogamous behavior.
In their experiment, Bales and team gave either a low, medium or high dose through the nose to 29 voles, and a saline solution to 14 controls. At first, the animals became all cuddly as in previous studies. But after three weeks, an entire vole childhood (from weaning to sexual maturity), they started breaking bad. Males did not engage in the normal behavior of “pair bonding,” that drives them to look for the girl of their dreams. And female voles’ natural mothering instinct seemed to disappear: When placed nearby young pups that were not their own, they didn’t dote, as they are wont to do. The cuddle hormone had turned the rodents into meanies.
Bales presented her work along with her graduate student Allison Perkeybile at the giant annual meeting of the Society of Neuroscience in New Orleans and the results are being published in the journal Biological Psychiatry. Just a vole study perhaps, but it might have some implications for use of the hormone in humans. Multiple clinical trials are under way to test oxytocin as a treatment for the social dysfunction that occurs in developmental disorders like autism and schizophrenia. Some physicians are already prescribing it off-label and it has taken on a cult status. Social commentator Naomi Wolfe, for one, called it “women’s emotional superpower.” And, of course, the buzz has fueled online sales.
The study showed one off-kilter effect that warrants caution for a parent that might want to try a little spritz up the nose of an autistic child. “I think the scariest thing to me was that the worst anti-social effects were at the lowest dose,” Bale says. ” And what’s also scary is that if you take your kid to the doctor, you’re going to want to start out at the lowest dose.”
“I don’t think we can count out oxytocin,” she continues, “but we have to be very careful with the dosing.” As always, more research is needed. Bales would like to know what would have happened if the animals had continued to receive the hormone as they matured. Until researchers come closer to an answer, though, it might be best to stay far away from the cuddle juice.
This story was originally published by Scientific American.